| 1. Henry C. Butler, b. 1845 [Father: natural] |
| 2. Nancy C. Butler, b. 1848 [Father: natural] |
| 3. Sarah Jane Butler, b. 1849 [Father: natural] |
| 4. James B. Butler, b. 1850 [Father: natural] |
| 5. Lucy Allen (Paddy) Butler, b. 1850 [Father: natural] |
| 6. Mary (Mattie) Butler, b. 1855 [Father: natural] |
| 7. William King Butler, b. 1856 [Father: natural] |
| 8. George Nathan Butler, b. 1858 d. 1934 (Age 76 years) [Father: natural] |
| 9. John Butler, b. 1859 [Father: natural] |
| 10. Caroline Butler, b. 1862 [Father: natural] |
| 11. Elizabeth Butler, b. 1863 [Father: natural] |
| 12. Joseph Butler, b. 1865 [Father: natural] |
| 13. Carroll Butler, b. 1868 [Father: natural] |